One accident. That's all it takes to potentially bankrupt a construction business in New York. The culprit? Action Over claims, a unique and often misunderstood aspect of insurance in the Empire State. If you're an artisan trade contractor operating in New York, understanding Action Over Coverage is absolutely critical to protecting your livelihood. This guide will explain why this coverage exists, how it affects your business, and how to navigate the complexities of purchasing it.
Why Does Action Over Coverage Exist in New York?
Action Over claims arise when an injured worker, already receiving workers' compensation benefits, sues a property owner or general contractor for additional damages. This is particularly significant in New York because of Labor Law 240 (the "Scaffold Law") and 241. These laws impose absolute liability on property owners and general contractors for elevation-related injuries, regardless of fault. This means that even if the worker's own negligence contributed to the accident (for example, if they weren't wearing a safety harness properly), the owner/GC can still be held fully liable. This starkly contrasts with most other states where workers' compensation is the sole remedy for workplace injuries. New York's unique laws allow injured workers to "take action over" against other parties, leading to massive settlements and skyrocketing insurance costs.
How Do Action Over Claims Impact Contractors?
Action Over claims can have devastating financial consequences. These claims often result in multi-million dollar settlements that can quickly deplete insurance limits. General contractors and property owners frequently shift this liability down the chain through contractual indemnification clauses, meaning subcontractors can be held responsible for substantial claims even if they weren't directly responsible for the accident. A history of Action Over claims can also make it incredibly difficult, sometimes even impossible, to secure affordable insurance in the future.
Real-World Claim Scenarios:
Scenario 1: A subcontractor's employee is working on scaffolding when a section collapses due to faulty installation by another subcontractor. Even though the injured worker is receiving workers' compensation, they sue the general contractor and property owner for negligence. Because of Labor Law 240, the GC and owner are held liable despite not being directly responsible for the collapse, resulting in a multi-million dollar settlement that the subcontractor's insurance (if they have it) may have to cover.
Scenario 2: A worker falls from a ladder due to a lack of proper fall protection equipment. While receiving workers' compensation, they file an Action Over claim against the property owner, alleging unsafe working conditions. Even if the worker contributed to the fall, the owner could be held fully liable due to the absolute liability imposed by Labor Law 240, leading to costly litigation and increased insurance premiums for all parties involved.
Why Can’t New Contractors Purchase Action Over Coverage Right Away?
One of the most frustrating aspects of Action Over coverage is that new trade contractors in New York often can't purchase it in their first year of business. Insurers require a minimum level of experience and a clean loss history before offering this high-risk coverage.
Why Insurers Require Experience:
Insurers are incredibly cautious with Action Over coverage due to several factors:
High Potential for Large Claims: As discussed, even seemingly minor accidents can result in massive payouts due to New York's unique legal environment.
Lack of Historical Data: New contractors lack a proven track record of safety and risk management. Insurers have no data to assess their risk profile, making them appear riskier.
Prioritizing Established Businesses: Carriers prefer to insure businesses with a demonstrated history of safe operations and claims management. They are more likely to have established relationships with brokers who can help them manage risk.
New contractors without Action Over coverage must be extremely selective about which projects they accept. They must carefully review contracts and ensure they do not take on contractual obligations they cannot meet.
What Can You Do If You Can't Get Action Over Coverage?
For those unable to secure Action Over coverage immediately, consider these risk management approaches:
Work Under a General Contractor’s Policy (Limited): Some GCs may offer limited coverage through a Controlled Insurance Program (CIP) or wrap-up policy. This means the subcontractor might be added as a named insured under the GC's policy for that specific project. However, these policies often have limitations and may not provide the same level of protection as a dedicated Action Over policy. Carefully review the terms of the CIP.
Negotiate Contract Terms (Crucial): Limit your exposure by negotiating contractual indemnification clauses. For example, instead of a broad indemnification clause, try to limit your liability to damages caused by your own negligence. Seek legal counsel to review contracts before signing.
What Happens If You Don’t Have Action Over Coverage?
Without Action Over coverage, trade contractors face financial ruin. A single claim can lead to out-of-pocket legal costs and settlements that can cripple a small business. It can also result in breach of contract issues if the contractor fails to meet insurance requirements. Additionally, contractors without proper coverage may lose out on future business opportunities due to ineligibility for jobs requiring Action Over coverage.
How to Ensure You Meet Insurance Requirements Before Bidding
Contractors should implement a Bid Qualification Process to ensure all insurance requirements—including Action Over coverage—are met before bidding on a project.
Steps to a Strong Bid Qualification Process:
Review the Contract Thoroughly: Scrutinize all insurance obligations, especially indemnity clauses and required Action Over coverage.
Check Insurance Requirements Early: Confirm whether Action Over coverage is mandatory before investing time and resources in bidding.
Work with an Insurance Broker: Have a qualified insurance broker review the contract to identify any gaps in your current coverage.
Request Updated Certificates of Insurance (COIs): Ensure all subcontractors and suppliers also carry the proper coverage, including Action Over if required.
Avoid Signing Risky Contracts: If the contract requires Action Over coverage that you don’t have and cannot obtain, walk away from the job. It’s better to lose a bid than your business.
What to Look for in Indemnification Clauses:
Many contractors don't realize that contracts they sign contain broad indemnification clauses, shifting liability to them even if an injury wasn’t their fault. Be wary of language like this: "The Subcontractor shall indemnify and hold harmless the Owner and General Contractor...from any and all claims...regardless of whether such claims are caused in whole or in part by the Owner or General Contractor." This type of clause makes you responsible even if the GC or owner is partially at fault.
How Does Action Over Coverage Impact Franchise Expansion?
Some larger brands avoid expanding into New York due to the high cost and legal exposure related to Action Over claims. Franchisees unaware of these risks may enter the market unprepared and face unanticipated expenses, leading to financial distress. Before committing to the New York market, franchisees should conduct a thorough insurance cost analysis and understand the full implications of Action Over coverage. Consult with an experienced insurance broker specializing in construction risks in New York.
How Can Franchisees Manage Risk Before a Lawsuit Happens?
Proactive risk management can significantly reduce your exposure to Action Over claims.
Implement Robust Safety Programs: Conduct weekly toolbox talks on critical safety topics like fall protection. Require all workers to complete OSHA 10-hour training and specialized training relevant to their tasks.
Formal Job-Site Risk Assessments: Develop a formal process to document safety compliance on every job site. Regular inspections and documented corrective actions are essential.
Meticulous Record Keeping: Keep detailed records of all incidents, including near misses. This documentation can be crucial in defending against claims and demonstrating a commitment to safety.
Why Should Franchisors and Franchisees Care About Action Over Coverage?
Franchisors and franchisees who oversee construction, maintenance, and repair operations must understand the complex implications of Action Over coverage to protect their business interests.
Conclusion:
Action Over Coverage is a critical, yet often complex, aspect of insurance for contractors in New York. By taking a strategic approach to insurance planning, risk management, and contract review, artisan trade contractors can operate successfully in New York while minimizing their exposure to costly and potentially devastating uninsured liabilities.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or insurance advice. Readers should consult with qualified legal and insurance professionals for guidance on their specific situation.
Comments